“Another toy destroyed… again.”
If this sounds like you every week, you’re not alone. Having a strong chewer in the house—whether it’s a teething puppy or a power-jawed adult dog—means regular toys just don’t make the cut. From pit bulls to labs, these enthusiastic chewers seem to have one mission: total toy annihilation.
But here’s the good news—you can outsmart those teeth with the right dog chew toys. So let’s sit down and talk about what really works, what’s safe, and which toys your dog won’t destroy within 5 minutes. Whether you’re looking for puppy training tools or the best dog toys for aggressive chewers, this guide is going to help you make smarter, longer-lasting toy choices.
Why Do Dogs Chew So Much?
Chewing is a natural instinct. Puppies chew to relieve teething pain, while adult dogs chew to clean their teeth, fight boredom, or deal with anxiety. But if your pup is leaving behind piles of shredded rubber and fabric, they need dog chew toys designed for strong jaws and persistent play.
Also Read: Sensitive Stomach Dog Food: What to Look for in 2025
What Makes a Dog Chew Toy Safe?
Not all toys are made equal, especially when it comes to super chewers. Here’s what to look for:
- Durability: Choose toys made of high-quality rubber or nylon. Soft plush toys may look cute but won’t last with a determined chewer.
- Non-toxic materials: Always go for BPA-free, phthalate-free materials—safety is non-negotiable.
- Size-appropriate: A toy too small can be swallowed; a toy too large may not be fun. Find the perfect fit for your dog’s breed and size.
- Purpose-driven design: Look for dog chew toys that double as dental cleaners, food puzzles, or training aids.
Our Top Picks for the Best Dog Chew Toys
1. Super Chewer Dog Toy – Vanilla Scented, Yellow and Blue
This one’s a fan favorite. Not only is it colorful and fun to toss, but it’s also made specifically for dogs that rip through everything else. The vanilla scent is a unique touch that dogs absolutely go nuts for. Built to survive strong jaws, it’s a great choice for daily chewing or fetch sessions.
2. Best Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers – Goughnuts MAXX Stick
You’ve probably heard the name before. Goughnuts are well-known for their indestructible toys. The MAXX Stick is nearly impossible to break and even comes with a safety indicator—if your dog chews through the outer layer, it’s time to replace. It’s a solid investment if you’re tired of throwing money at cheap toys that don’t last.
3. Best Toys for Pit Bulls – West Paw Zogoflex Tux
Pit bulls are some of the strongest chewers out there, so their toys need to be next-level tough. This toy does double duty—it’s a chew toy and a treat dispenser. Stuff it with frozen peanut butter or biscuits to keep your dog busy for hours. Bonus? It’s dishwasher-safe and made in the USA.
4. Really Tough Dog Toys – Kong Extreme
Let’s be honest—no chew toy list is complete without Kong. The Extreme version is perfect for aggressive chewers. Durable, stuffable, and bounceable, it keeps your pup entertained and your furniture safe.
5. Toys for Heavy Dog Chewers – Benebone Wishbone
This nylon-based toy is shaped like a wishbone and flavored with real bacon. Its unique design makes it easy for dogs to hold and chew. Made in the U.S., it’s ideal for dogs who chew constantly but aren’t into plush or rubber toys.
6. Best Chew Toys for Puppies – Nylabone Teething Rings
Got a puppy who’s chewing everything in sight? These rings are soft enough for young teeth but tough enough to last. They soothe teething pain and discourage bad habits like chewing on shoes or furniture.
Tips to Make Chew Toys Last Longer
Even the best dog chew toys won’t last forever—but with these tips, you can stretch their lifespan:
- Rotate toys weekly to keep your dog interested.
- Use them during training to reinforce good chewing behavior.
- Clean them regularly to avoid bacteria buildup and preserve their material.
Warning Signs to Replace a Chew Toy
Even durable toys eventually break down. Replace any toy that has:
- Sharp edges or torn parts
- Missing chunks
- Exposed inner material
If in doubt, throw it out—better safe than sorry!
A Must Read: How to spot mange in your dog early
Final Woof: Don’t Compromise on Safety or Durability
We know it’s frustrating to keep buying toys your dog destroys in seconds. But the right dog chew toys can keep them occupied, satisfied, and even healthier. Whether you’re raising a teething puppy or trying to outlast your pit bull’s jaw strength, there’s a perfect match out there.
Still confused about which one to get? Check out real reviews from pet parents on MyPetPit, or drop us a message—we’re here to help you make the right choice for your heavy chewer.
